A typology of four notions of confounding in epidemiology
نویسندگان
چکیده
Confounding is a major concern in epidemiology. Despite its significance, the different notions of confounding have not been fully appreciated in the literature, leading to confusion of causal concepts in epidemiology. In this article, we aim to highlight the importance of differentiating between the subtly different notions of confounding from the perspective of counterfactual reasoning. By using a simple example, we illustrate the significance of considering the distribution of response types to distinguish causation from association, highlighting that confounding depends not only on the population chosen as the target of inference, but also on the notions of confounding in distribution and confounding in measure. This point has been relatively underappreciated, partly because some literature on the concept of confounding has only used the exposed and unexposed groups as the target populations, while it would be helpful to use the total population as the target population. Moreover, to clarify a further distinction between confounding "in expectation" and "realized" confounding, we illustrate the usefulness of examining the distribution of exposure status in the target population. To grasp the explicit distinction between confounding in expectation and realized confounding, we need to understand the mechanism that generates exposure events, not the product of that mechanism. Finally, we graphically illustrate this point, highlighting the usefulness of directed acyclic graphs in examining the presence of confounding in distribution, in the notion of confounding in expectation.
منابع مشابه
Typology of spirituality in relation with spiritual health
Introduction: today, spiritual health is considered as the forth dimension of health, and its public acceptance is a result of the considerable influence that spirituality generally has on other dimensions of health. The purpose of this review is to introduce the variouse types of spiritual health. Methods: In this review study on the typology of spirituality, books and disserations that were w...
متن کاملThe Typology of EFL Teachers’ Codeswitching: A Validation Study
The use of L1 in language classroom has been traditionally repressed by applied linguists. However, in recent years, it is believed that switching to L1 can be considered a pedagogical instrument by teachers rather than a heterodox. Consequently, this two-phase study was an attempt to investigate the functions that are fulfilled by EFL teachers through their use of L1. In the first phase (i.e.,...
متن کاملTypology of Tarmeh in the Historic city of Bushehr
In the Architecture of Iran, the vernacular architecture of Bushehr’s historic city is distinctive since it is both introverted and extroverted and has different semi-open interior and exterior spaces. Tarameh is one of these semi-open spaces. Using a qualitative research method, conducting desk and field studies and reviewing the technical documents of the historic buildings of Bushehr, this p...
متن کاملTypology of Farmers' Behavior and Attitudes towards Occupational Health in Agriculture, Kermanshah province
Background and Aims: All over the world, agriculture is one of the most important and accident-prone jobs in the world. Occupational health behavior is one of the most important factors influencing the occurrence of accidents and diseases caused by agriculture activities. Therefore, the aim of the present study was investigated the typology of farmers' behavior and attitudes towards agricultur...
متن کامل